Election officials in a key battleground state have opened an investigation after 388 Election Day votes were omitted from initial unofficial results in a state House race, reversing which candidate was leading.The discrepancy occurred in Seminole County in southwest Georgia during Tuesday’s midterm elections and affected the closely contested House District 154 race.
Democratic challenger Harry James initially led longtime incumbent Republican Rep. Gerald Greene by 58 votes.
After the additional Seminole County results were processed, Greene moved ahead by 262 votes, according to Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger’s office.
The dramatic reversal was discovered during routine post-election checks.State officials found approximately 388 more voters had been recorded as checking in at Seminole County polling locations than the number of ballots included in the county’s reported Election Day results.
The Secretary of State’s office contacted county election officials about the discrepancy.
Raffensperger’s office said the Seminole County Board of Elections subsequently determined that a memory card containing election results had not been uploaded into the county’s election management system.“Georgia’s election safeguards are designed to identify discrepancies, and that is exactly what these guardrails did,” Raffensperger said.
“Our office identified a significant discrepancy, alerted county officials, and uncovered a failure to properly upload election results,” he continued.
“This oversight didn’t just affect the numbers – it changed who was leading an election. That is unacceptable, and we intend to find out exactly how it happened.”
Seminole County Elections Supervisor Ron Foskey, however, disputed reports describing the memory card as missing or newly discovered.
“There was no memory card ‘discovered’, ‘missing’, or ‘found’,” Foskey said.
“All precinct card chain of custody protocols were followed, and all memory cards were accounted for by the Seminole County Board of Elections on Election night.”
According to Foskey, the problem instead involved the county’s Election Management System failing to complete processing of the final precinct’s memory card.
“The Election Management System computer did not complete its program for the last precincts memory card,” Foskey said.
The county’s initial Election Summary Report was marked “Unofficial and Incomplete,” he added.
Foskey said election workers determined Friday that the final step required to validate and publish the results had not been completed.
“This step was accomplished and the program run was successfully completed,” he said.
The resulting report was marked “Final and Complete” and included 388 additional ballots that had not appeared in the initial unofficial report.
Advertisement
County officials said the final total matched the number of ballots counted, ballot scanner tapes and information stored on the memory cards.
The Secretary of State’s investigation will examine exactly how the results were omitted, whether election workers followed required procedures and what corrective measures may be necessary.
“Every vote matters, and in a close election, even a relatively small number of unreported ballots can change the outcome,” Raffensperger said.
The House District 154 contest remains particularly consequential because Democrats captured control of the Georgia House in Tuesday’s elections.
Democrats flipped numerous Republican-held seats as part of their statewide gains.
Greene’s apparent survival would narrow the incoming Democratic majority.
The veteran lawmaker has served in the Georgia House for decades, first winning election in 1982 as a Democrat before switching to the Republican Party after the 2010 election.
House District 154 covers a large portion of southwest Georgia and includes Seminole County.
James had appeared positioned to defeat Greene before the additional votes were included.
No public evidence has emerged indicating the 388 ballots were fraudulent, improperly cast or added after Election Day.
The dispute centers instead on why results associated with the ballots were not included in the county’s initial reporting.
That distinction has become important as state officials and Seminole County officials offer somewhat different descriptions of what occurred.
Raffensperger’s office described the incident as a failure to upload election results from a memory card, while county officials maintain every memory card was accounted for and the problem occurred during the computer processing and publishing procedure.
The state investigation is expected to determine precisely where the failure occurred.
County election officials faced a Monday deadline to certify their results.
Until certification and any subsequent challenges are completed, Greene’s lead over James remains unofficial.
