Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman said he would consider leaving the Democratic Party if Sen. Chris Van Hollen replaces Chuck Schumer as the party’s Senate leader, citing sharp disagreements over Israel.
Fetterman made the comments as Senate Democrats prepare for an unusually contentious leadership election following Van Hollen’s decision to challenge Schumer.
Asked whether he would consider leaving the Democratic caucus if Van Hollen wins, Fetterman said it was possible.
“Absolutely, I would consider it,” Fetterman said.
The Pennsylvania senator pointed specifically to Van Hollen’s record on Israel, an issue that has increasingly divided Democrats since the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas terrorist attack.
Fetterman has emerged as one of Israel’s most outspoken Democratic supporters in Congress and has repeatedly criticized members of his party whom he believes have abandoned the longtime U.S. ally.
Van Hollen has been far more critical of the Israeli government and its military operations in Gaza.
The Maryland Democrat has pushed for restrictions on U.S. military assistance to Israel and criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government over civilian casualties and humanitarian conditions in Gaza.
Fetterman argued that elevating Van Hollen to lead Senate Democrats would represent a major change in the party’s approach to Israel.
Van Hollen announced Thursday that he would challenge Schumer for the Democratic leadership position.
“In this election, Americans called on us to unrig an economy rigged against working people & fueled by political corruption,” Van Hollen wrote. “To deliver, we need new leadership. This isn’t about any one person – it’s about answering that call. That’s why I’m running.”
The decision represented a reversal for Van Hollen, who previously indicated he was not planning to seek the leadership job.
Independent Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, who caucuses with Democrats, quickly endorsed Van Hollen.
“I personally have known Chuck Schumer for over 30 years, and I like Chuck. Nobody who works harder than Chuck Schumer,” Sanders said.
“But in my view, the time is now for change, and I will not be supporting Chuck to be re-elected as the Democratic leader.”
Van Hollen has also received support from some newly elected far-left Democrats seeking a change in the party’s leadership.
Fetterman’s warning demonstrates that Van Hollen’s candidacy could create significant resistance from the party’s pro-Israel members.
Fetterman has frequently broken with Democrats since entering the Senate in 2023.
He has supported tougher border enforcement, criticized progressive rhetoric surrounding immigration and strongly backed Israel throughout its conflict with Hamas and other Iranian-backed groups.
He has also maintained a willingness to work with President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans on certain issues.
Despite those disagreements, Fetterman has repeatedly rejected previous speculation that he was preparing to become a Republican.
His latest comments go further by explicitly leaving open the possibility of departing the Democratic Party depending on the outcome of the leadership contest.
Fetterman escalated his criticism of the Democratic Party’s progressive wing Saturday, saying he no longer sees “any more common ground” with the far left over its position on Israel.
During an appearance on Fox News’ “Saturday in America,” Fetterman criticized the movement to replace Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer with Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen and also attacked his newly announced 2028 Democratic primary challenger.
“I don’t know if there’s any more common ground with this far-left wing,” Fetterman said.
Fetterman has emerged as one of Israel’s most outspoken Democratic supporters since the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas terrorist attack and has repeatedly clashed with progressive members of his party over the issue.
The latest dispute comes as Van Hollen challenges Schumer for leadership of Senate Democrats.
Fetterman has made clear that Van Hollen’s positions on Israel are a major concern for him.
“I’m going to support Schumer,” Fetterman said Saturday. “I absolutely disagree with some of the things that he’s done, but he’s always been strongly pro-Israel.”
Fetterman argued that replacing Schumer with Van Hollen would move Senate Democrats further away from his own position on the U.S.-Israel alliance.
The Pennsylvania Democrat also took aim at progressive state Rep. Rick Krajewski, who announced last week that he will challenge Fetterman in Pennsylvania’s 2028 Democratic Senate primary.
Krajewski represents a Philadelphia-area district and is backed by progressive organizations.
Fetterman labeled his challenger “pro-Hamas” during the Fox interview, pointing to Krajewski’s previous statements and activism concerning Israel and Gaza.
Krajewski has called for restrictions on U.S. weapons transfers to Israel and has accused the Israeli government of committing genocide in Gaza.
He has also criticized Fetterman’s strong support for Israel.
Fetterman showed little concern about facing a primary challenge. “I welcome that primary,” he said.
