Courtroom Defeat For Dems: Key Senate Race Battle Goes Republicans’ Way

Democrats suffered a courtroom defeat Wednesday in the country’s last uncalled Senate race as election officials continued counting ballots.

The campaign wanted information from election officials, and a judge found the request unreasonable with counting deadlines approaching.

Alaska Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews rejected Democrat Mary Peltola’s request to identify voters whose absentee ballots had been rejected.

Peltola is running against Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, a two-term incumbent, in a race that remained too early to call.

Her campaign sued state officials Friday seeking voters’ names and the reasons the Division of Elections rejected their ballots.

The campaign’s attorneys said the records would help ensure all qualified voters had their ballots counted in the Senate contest.

State attorneys argued the request raised privacy concerns and would divert staff from counting ballots and meeting election deadlines.

Matthews called the request “not reasonable” given the work still facing election officials as they count last week’s ballots.

“The timing of the Campaign’s request could simply not be worse,” Matthews wrote.

Matthews said the information might be releasable “in theory” if officials could extract it from the database and redact it.

He concluded that the requested records “cannot reasonably be produced at this juncture, nor redacted of confidential information.”

The division told the court its employees were already working long hours to meet deadlines for administering the election.

Matthews described administering elections as the division’s “fundamental responsibility” as he weighed the campaign’s request against the agency’s workload.

The ruling addressed the campaign’s access to records while election officials continued reviewing and tallying absentee ballots.

State lawyers argued that generating a list from the voter database would amount to creating an “electronic service or product.”

They said state law allows the agency to give its primary responsibilities priority over producing that kind of report.

Peltola campaign attorney Abha Khanna told Matthews on Tuesday the campaign had no intention of disrupting the ongoing ballot count.

She described absentee review as going “incredibly smoothly” and argued the requested information was a matter of public record.

Khanna said campaign observers could already see similar information at locations where absentee review boards were meeting.

She said the campaign wanted a centralized way to access that information during the review, without relying on individual locations.

State attorneys called the reports “ephemeral working documents that are not meant for preservation” and said they contained confidential information.

Michaela Thompson, who oversees the division’s absentee ballot review boards, explained how officials handle that information in an affidavit.

Thompson said reports shown to observers contain less confidential information than the versions election officials use for their own work.

Even those observer versions include home addresses that many voters want to keep private, Thompson told the court.

Observers sign confidentiality agreements before reviewing the reports and cannot keep copies or write down the information they see.

Those restrictions apply to campaign observers as well as others permitted to view reports during the absentee review process.

Thompson described the database as “old, inflexible” and said it cannot produce a report that leaves out confidential addresses.

The division previously said it had long treated preliminary absentee ballot information as confidential because decisions can change during review.

She said the division would need to work with a vendor to create a report tailored to the campaign’s request.

Those limits shaped the dispute over whether election staff could deliver a usable list within the campaign’s timeframe.

Requests for comment from a firm representing Peltola’s campaign and the state Department of Law went unanswered Wednesday, a holiday.

Alaska accepts overseas ballots for 15 days after a general election, giving those ballots until November 18 to arrive.

The Division of Elections is also targeting November 18 for ranked-choice tabulation if nobody clears 50% of the first-choice vote, NBC News reported.

That threshold determines whether officials need to move beyond the first-choice count and begin processing voters’ remaining rankings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *